I followed the instructions from this tutorial:  Setting up membership in Umbraco and it works...  kind of.  I get the login page, I can enter the users name and password and it passes correctly, however I don't get redirected to the main page, I instead just see the login page, again.  

I'm trying to password protect the entire site.  This site was hosted on an Umbraco install with multiple other sites but I could never get the Memberships to work right so I broke it off to it's own install and I now get this.  

I didn't put the login page in the main template as I want it to look different from the site and I also added the login page to the root instead of inside the website's folder in the content view.  I'm sure I'm missing something but I just can't figure it out.  Any help would be awesome.